Transnegation Roundup/2020/09/13/1

Jump to navigation Jump to search

Sex Is Just Reproduction... and genitals, hormones, chromosomes, ruthless efficiency, nice red uniforms...

  • 2020-09-12 20:40 @WELSH_GURL_99 But what about women who cannot get pregnant? / You still haven't given me a good answer on this
    • 2020-09-12 22:54 @zaelefty What about strawmans that never seem to go away?
      • 2020-09-13 08:09 @ZeeZeeMooMoo Thats not what a fucking strawman is / You people are literally trying to define women by pregnancy
        • 2020-09-13 09:21 @Delilahdern Womanhood is not appearance, character or sexuality. There are all kinds of human, and about half of them are female. Woman means the sex that produces ova, men means the sex that produces sperm.
          • 2020-09-13 09:21 @Delilahdern That's it, it's not deeper than that. Sex is genitals, reproduction, hormones, chromosomes. That doesn't mean women are only those things, but that those thing define them as women. After all, women are complex human beings. Being a woman is not dependant on heels or makeup.
            • 09:23 @ZeeZeeMooMoo youve just listed a bunch of things that dont correspond / some people have certain chromosomes that wouldnt match the hormones and genitals you expect, etc etc

ZeeZee's points are exactly right.

  • A straw man is a weakened misrepresentation of someone else's position (something that Gender Criticals frequently do to trans people).
  • What do you do when some of the indicators don't line up the way you expect?