Difference between revisions of "Myths/Humans cannot change sex"

From CWRE
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Woozle moved page Myths/Humans cannot change sex. to Myths/Humans cannot change sex without leaving a redirect: didn't mean to include the period)
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 8: Line 8:
 
* You cannot change your gender.
 
* You cannot change your gender.
 
* Sex isn't "assigned" at birth.<ref name=tpd-2018-03-05 />
 
* Sex isn't "assigned" at birth.<ref name=tpd-2018-03-05 />
 +
 +
It is typically used as an argument against:
 +
* the idea that trans people are genuinely the gender they say they are
 +
** ...and therefore against the idea that they deserve access to spaces and privileges of their gender identity rather than their birth-assigned gender...
 +
*** ''especially'' female spaces/privileges, most notably:
 +
*** access to women's bathrooms
 +
*** competing athletically as women
 +
* {{l/ip|sex reassignment surgery}} (funding it, allowing access to it, and/or providing it<ref name=PMcH-2004-11 />)
 
==Reality==
 
==Reality==
 
These claims tend to ignore or dismiss several decades of scientific discovery in the understanding of sex and gender, while others try to blur the lines between sex and gender. In general, they also focus on one aspect of sex while ignoring the reason that people seek SRS.
 
These claims tend to ignore or dismiss several decades of scientific discovery in the understanding of sex and gender, while others try to blur the lines between sex and gender. In general, they also focus on one aspect of sex while ignoring the reason that people seek SRS.
* "You cannot change your sex." -- this is an ambiguous statement open to multiple interpretations:
+
* "'''You cannot change your sex.'''" -- this is an ambiguous statement open to multiple interpretations:
 
** If "your sex" is defined as...
 
** If "your sex" is defined as...
 
*** "your biological role in reproduction" (as one myth-source article<ref name=tpd-2018-03-05 /> defines it), then you certainly can do so by means of any operation that renders one sterile. Sterilization is not, however, the only reason transgender people seek SRS; if it were, then mere removal of the gonads (or vasectomy, for male bodies) would suffice.
 
*** "your biological role in reproduction" (as one myth-source article<ref name=tpd-2018-03-05 /> defines it), then you certainly can do so by means of any operation that renders one sterile. Sterilization is not, however, the only reason transgender people seek SRS; if it were, then mere removal of the gonads (or vasectomy, for male bodies) would suffice.
 
*** something else, then what is that?
 
*** something else, then what is that?
 
** If "change" means "reverse" (rather than "in some way alter"), then trans people are certainly not seeking SRS for that reason, as medical technology does not yet permit the transformation of a reproductively-male body into a reproductively-female body, although current progress makes it likely that this will be possible in a matter of decades at most. (One feels compelled to wonder if anti-SRS advocates will stop raising this objection once that happens.)
 
** If "change" means "reverse" (rather than "in some way alter"), then trans people are certainly not seeking SRS for that reason, as medical technology does not yet permit the transformation of a reproductively-male body into a reproductively-female body, although current progress makes it likely that this will be possible in a matter of decades at most. (One feels compelled to wonder if anti-SRS advocates will stop raising this objection once that happens.)
* "You cannot change your gender" is technically true. When transgender people transition, however, they are not attempting to do this. They are attempting to alter their body's physical gender (primary and secondary sexual characteristics) to match their gender<ref name=bodymap />. Again we come to the question of "why does it matter if this is true?"
+
* "'''Human biological sex is immutable'''" is either defining "biological sex" to ''specifically'' mean reproductive role, or else is conflating the many aspects of biological sex into one and claiming that none of them can be changed, which is patently false.
 +
* "'''You cannot change your gender'''" is true as stated, and indeed is a fundamental basis of how {{l/ip|gender identity}} works. When transgender people transition, however, they are not attempting to change their gender. They are attempting to alter their body's physical gender (primary and secondary sexual characteristics) to match their gender<ref name=bodymap />. Again we come to the question of "why does it matter if this is true?"
 
** Worse, there's often an implication that a (trans) person whose physical gender is A but who identifies as B is "changing their gender" to B -- when in fact it has been B all along; see {{l/ip|gender identity}}.
 
** Worse, there's often an implication that a (trans) person whose physical gender is A but who identifies as B is "changing their gender" to B -- when in fact it has been B all along; see {{l/ip|gender identity}}.
* "Sex isn't "assigned" at birth." may be true, depending on what you mean by "assigned"; see {{l/ip|sex assignment}}.
+
* "'''Sex isn't "assigned" at birth.'''" may be true, depending on what you mean by "assigned"; see {{l/ip|sex assignment}}.
 
===Blurring the lines===
 
===Blurring the lines===
* "You cannot change your sex" is ambiguous in at least a couple of ways, either implying an outright falsehood or implying that SRS has a particular goal which it does not actually have.
+
* "'''You cannot change your sex'''" is ambiguous in at least a couple of ways, either implying an outright falsehood or implying that SRS has a particular goal which it does not actually have.
* "You cannot change your gender" blurs the lines between "sex" and "gender": trans people are not attempting to "change gender", so why argue that it can't be done?
+
* "'''You cannot change your gender'''" blurs the lines between "sex" and "gender": trans people are not attempting to "change gender", so why argue that it can't be done?
 +
* "'''Sex isn't "assigned" at birth'''" is either true and undisputed, if "assigned" means "chosen arbitrarily", or else plainly false if "assigned" means "determined from the physical evidence". The meaning of "assigned" is being blurred here.
 
===Issue Unclear===
 
===Issue Unclear===
* "You cannot change your sex", if taken to mean "you cannot convert a body from one reproductive role to the other", is certainly true within the limits of current medical technology.
+
* "'''You cannot change your sex'''", if taken to mean "you cannot convert a body from one reproductive role to the other", is certainly true within the limits of current medical technology.
* "You cannot change your gender" states a truth that trans advocates do not dispute.
+
* "'''You cannot change your gender'''" states a truth that trans advocates strongly support. (If gender could be changed, then transition would probably be unnecessary.)
  
 
If these are the intended interpretations, trans advocates do not dispute them &ndash; so why state them except as {{l/ip|straw man argument}}s? If these are ''not'' the intended interpretations, then how were they supposed to be interpreted? Either way, they should be stated less ambiguously.
 
If these are the intended interpretations, trans advocates do not dispute them &ndash; so why state them except as {{l/ip|straw man argument}}s? If these are ''not'' the intended interpretations, then how were they supposed to be interpreted? Either way, they should be stated less ambiguously.
 
===Moving Goalposts===
 
===Moving Goalposts===
* "Human biological sex is immutable" is a retreat from the older position that biological sex itself is immutable<ref name=tg-2019-12-18 />, which is flatly contradicted by the existence of a number of animal species which change their reproductive functioning over a normal lifetime.
+
* "'''Human biological sex is immutable'''" is a retreat from the older position that biological sex itself is immutable<ref name=tg-2019-12-18 />, which is flatly contradicted by the existence of a number of animal species which change their reproductive functioning over a normal lifetime.
  
 
==See also==
 
==See also==
Line 34: Line 44:
 
==Footnotes==
 
==Footnotes==
 
<references>
 
<references>
<ref name=tg-2019-12-18>'''2019-12-18''' [https://www.theguardian.com/society/2019/dec/18/judge-rules-against-charity-worker-who-lost-job-over-transgender-tweets Judge rules against researcher who lost job over transgender tweets] quotes Maya Forstater: "My belief [...] is that sex is a biological fact, and is immutable. There are two sexes, male and female. Men and boys are male. Women and girls are female. It is impossible to change sex. These were until very recently understood as basic facts of life by almost everyone."</ref>
+
<ref name=tg-2019-12-18>{{l/ip/fl|2019/12/18|Judge rules against researcher who lost job over transgender tweets}} quotes Maya Forstater: "My belief [...] is that sex is a biological fact, and is immutable. There are two sexes, male and female. Men and boys are male. Women and girls are female. It is impossible to change sex. These were until very recently understood as basic facts of life by almost everyone."</ref>
 
<ref name=tpd-2018-03-05>{{l/ip/fl|2018/03/05|Sex Change Physically Impossible Psychosocially Unhelpful and Philosophically Misguided}}:
 
<ref name=tpd-2018-03-05>{{l/ip/fl|2018/03/05|Sex Change Physically Impossible Psychosocially Unhelpful and Philosophically Misguided}}:
 
* "sex isn’t 'assigned' at birth &ndash; and that’s why it can't be 'reassigned.'"
 
* "sex isn’t 'assigned' at birth &ndash; and that’s why it can't be 'reassigned.'"
Line 42: Line 52:
 
* "Transgendered men do not become women, nor do transgendered women become men." (quoting {{l/ip|Paul McHugh}})</ref>
 
* "Transgendered men do not become women, nor do transgendered women become men." (quoting {{l/ip|Paul McHugh}})</ref>
 
<ref name=bodymap>or, more precisely, to match their brain's body-map with regard to gender. As with everything relating to gender, preference for one sexual characteristic does not automatically mean preference for all the others, though there is a high correlation.</ref>
 
<ref name=bodymap>or, more precisely, to match their brain's body-map with regard to gender. As with everything relating to gender, preference for one sexual characteristic does not automatically mean preference for all the others, though there is a high correlation.</ref>
 +
<ref name=PMcH-2004-11>'''2004/11''' [[issuepedia:2004/11/Surgical Sex|Surgical Sex: Why We Stopped Doing Sex Change Operations]]</ref>
 
</references>
 
</references>

Latest revision as of 20:56, 25 June 2020

Myth: Humans cannot change sex.

Myth

This claim has been expressed in a number of different ways:

  • You cannot change your sex.[1][2]
  • Human biological sex is immutable.
  • You cannot change your gender.
  • Sex isn't "assigned" at birth.[1]

It is typically used as an argument against:

  • the idea that trans people are genuinely the gender they say they are
    • ...and therefore against the idea that they deserve access to spaces and privileges of their gender identity rather than their birth-assigned gender...
      • especially female spaces/privileges, most notably:
      • access to women's bathrooms
      • competing athletically as women
  • sex reassignment surgery (funding it, allowing access to it, and/or providing it[3])

Reality

These claims tend to ignore or dismiss several decades of scientific discovery in the understanding of sex and gender, while others try to blur the lines between sex and gender. In general, they also focus on one aspect of sex while ignoring the reason that people seek SRS.

  • "You cannot change your sex." -- this is an ambiguous statement open to multiple interpretations:
    • If "your sex" is defined as...
      • "your biological role in reproduction" (as one myth-source article[1] defines it), then you certainly can do so by means of any operation that renders one sterile. Sterilization is not, however, the only reason transgender people seek SRS; if it were, then mere removal of the gonads (or vasectomy, for male bodies) would suffice.
      • something else, then what is that?
    • If "change" means "reverse" (rather than "in some way alter"), then trans people are certainly not seeking SRS for that reason, as medical technology does not yet permit the transformation of a reproductively-male body into a reproductively-female body, although current progress makes it likely that this will be possible in a matter of decades at most. (One feels compelled to wonder if anti-SRS advocates will stop raising this objection once that happens.)
  • "Human biological sex is immutable" is either defining "biological sex" to specifically mean reproductive role, or else is conflating the many aspects of biological sex into one and claiming that none of them can be changed, which is patently false.
  • "You cannot change your gender" is true as stated, and indeed is a fundamental basis of how gender identity works. When transgender people transition, however, they are not attempting to change their gender. They are attempting to alter their body's physical gender (primary and secondary sexual characteristics) to match their gender[4]. Again we come to the question of "why does it matter if this is true?"
    • Worse, there's often an implication that a (trans) person whose physical gender is A but who identifies as B is "changing their gender" to B -- when in fact it has been B all along; see gender identity.
  • "Sex isn't "assigned" at birth." may be true, depending on what you mean by "assigned"; see sex assignment.

Blurring the lines

  • "You cannot change your sex" is ambiguous in at least a couple of ways, either implying an outright falsehood or implying that SRS has a particular goal which it does not actually have.
  • "You cannot change your gender" blurs the lines between "sex" and "gender": trans people are not attempting to "change gender", so why argue that it can't be done?
  • "Sex isn't "assigned" at birth" is either true and undisputed, if "assigned" means "chosen arbitrarily", or else plainly false if "assigned" means "determined from the physical evidence". The meaning of "assigned" is being blurred here.

Issue Unclear

  • "You cannot change your sex", if taken to mean "you cannot convert a body from one reproductive role to the other", is certainly true within the limits of current medical technology.
  • "You cannot change your gender" states a truth that trans advocates strongly support. (If gender could be changed, then transition would probably be unnecessary.)

If these are the intended interpretations, trans advocates do not dispute them – so why state them except as straw man arguments? If these are not the intended interpretations, then how were they supposed to be interpreted? Either way, they should be stated less ambiguously.

Moving Goalposts

  • "Human biological sex is immutable" is a retreat from the older position that biological sex itself is immutable[2], which is flatly contradicted by the existence of a number of animal species which change their reproductive functioning over a normal lifetime.

See also

Footnotes

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 2018/03/05 Sex Change Physically Impossible Psychosocially Unhelpful and Philosophically Misguided:
    • "sex isn’t 'assigned' at birth – and that’s why it can't be 'reassigned.'"
    • "Cosmetic surgery and cross-sex hormones can’t change us into the opposite sex. [..] They can’t turn us from one sex into the other."
    • "transgender men are not biological men and transgender women are not biological women." (quoting Dr. Lawrence Mayer)
    • "Changing sexes is a metaphysical impossibility because it is a biological impossibility." (quoting philosopher Robert P. George)
    • "Transgendered men do not become women, nor do transgendered women become men." (quoting Paul McHugh)
  2. 2.0 2.1 2019/12/18 Judge rules against researcher who lost job over transgender tweets quotes Maya Forstater: "My belief [...] is that sex is a biological fact, and is immutable. There are two sexes, male and female. Men and boys are male. Women and girls are female. It is impossible to change sex. These were until very recently understood as basic facts of life by almost everyone."
  3. 2004/11 Surgical Sex: Why We Stopped Doing Sex Change Operations
  4. or, more precisely, to match their brain's body-map with regard to gender. As with everything relating to gender, preference for one sexual characteristic does not automatically mean preference for all the others, though there is a high correlation.